July 15, 2009

This? or This?

Here's a little game Lauren and I like to play when we've got a moment to spare (usually when we're stuck in traffic). It's good old-fashioned "This? or This?", a ridiculous question of zero importance, but whose answer ends up being weirdly revealing about someone's personality. (I should say that normally we try not to judge others, but this can be pretty entertaining). Anyway...I thought it might be fun to try this out here on Smarts & Crafts. It's pretty straightforward, every once in a while I'll demand you choose between "this or this" and you can respond in the comments. Please play along if you're so inclined...

So here we go. We've got two very talented gentlemen, Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys, and David Bowie, the guy from 'Labyrinth'. So who do you choose? Who's your man? And remember, we're not judging by the photo here, or whether one was a snazzier dresser, or even whose music you like better. We judging by who these people are. If you take a moment to think about it, it's actually really hard to choose. But you must. So who's it gonna be?

Okay, now this one is even harder. Good Luck!

23 comments:

Derek said...

I'll go first:
Brian
Cake

Lauren said...

Aha it's my favorite game!

I beg to differ with your choices though- I say:
David Bowie (tough choice though)
&
Pie (of course)

!!!

Abbey said...

Hard to choose, but if we're talking the people and not their work necessarily, you gotta go with Bowie, who seems to at least be able to function in the world without a bathrobe or a guru. Sad.

Also, pie is gross.

Sarah Janet said...

Easy:

Bowie (better music)
cake (can't go wrong with chocolate)

caroline said...

boe
cake

caroline said...

aka bowie. what was i smokin'

Deb said...

Bowie and always always always CAKE before pie:)

Conn said...

Bowie
+
Cake

Kari said...

David Bowie & Cherry Pie!

kate said...

I'm with Conn:
Bowie + Cake

I love this game.

erin said...

I pick (the first with this combo):

Brian

+

Pie

ilana said...

Maybe I'm being predictable but -

1. Bowie though I'm loving Wilson's 'Help Me Rhonda' shirt in that photo

2. Pie. Yes. Pie

sophia said...

okay, i'm in on this.
bowie...and CAKE!!!

Joby said...

bowie and cake all the way!

Adam said...

I'm with you Derek:
Brian Wilson and cake

Treehouse Collective said...

Yes, Brian & cake!

ModFruGal said...

Bowie Pie!

Mandy Kay said...

how about a pie-covered David Bowie??? yummy. love me some bowie!

Another Kristin said...

Bowie + Pie -- fun game!

Elizabeth MacCrellish said...

ohhh, this is TOUGH-- at least between Brian and Bowie . . but I guess if I must choose it will be BOWIE .. and I don't like pie so I guess cake-- but could I just have Bowie AND Brian instead and no dessert? *smile*

Bisous, Elizabeth

smitty said...

Bowie!
and Cake!

kate said...

Bowie, because his integrity has lasted a lot longer, and I think he's still incredibly cool and seems to still give a crap about music. Although I need to make me one of those Help Me Rhonda tee's.

And Cake.

victoria said...

i so love this! and it's hard!

especially brian vs. bowie. but i'll go bowie.

and cake. no pie. no cake!